Dallas Fed Kaplan: Trade rhetoric could have chilling effect

    Dallas Fed President Robert Kaplan reiterated his expectation for two for rate hikes this year. And, 2018 is seen a a relatively solid year for growth to him. But Kaplan also noted that it is going to be watching the yield curve “very carefully”. And he won’t “blindly” support rate hikes if yield curve keeps flattening.

    In addition, like other Fed officials, Kaplan said it’s “too early to judge” how the trade spat between the US and China is going to affect the economy. But he warned that if the rhetoric goes on for long enough at this level, it is “having somewhat a chilling effect”.

    He added that “I’m still hopeful when we look back a year or two from now you’ll see very little actually done in the way of tariffs that were implemented”. And, “that would be my base case, and I think we are in the early innings of this.”

    Markets respond positively to China Xi Jinping’s calm but uninspiring speech at Boao, AUD up, JPY down

      The financial markets are responding positively to China President Xi Jinping’s calm but uninspiring speech at the  Boao Forum for Asia today. At the time of writing, Nikkei is trading up 1%, Hong Kong HSI is up 0.9%. JPY is deeply lower at the current 4 hour bar while commodity currencies show much strength. This is a clear sign of risk appetite.

      Zero-sum game thinking is outdated

      Xi urged the world not to return to “Cold War” mentality. He said that “human society is facing a major choice to open or close, to go forward or backward.” And, “in today’s world, the trend of peace and cooperation is moving forward and a Cold War mentality and zero-sum game thinking are outdated.”

      And, he added that “paying attention only to one’s own community without thinking of others can only lead into a wall.” XI urged that “we can only achieve win-win results by insisting on peaceful development and working together.”

      Stay committed to multilateral frameworks

      Regarding trade, Xi said that “China does not seek trade surplus. We have a genuine desire to increase imports and achieve greater balance of international payments under the current account.” And, “we hope developed countries will stop imposing restrictions on normal and reasonable trade of high-tech products and relax export controls on such trade with China.”

      Xi also emphasized the need to “stay committed to openness, connectivity and mutual benefits, build an open global economy, and reinforce cooperation within the G-20, APEC and other multilateral frameworks”.

      China to further open up

      Xi also talked about the plans to further open up the massive Chinese markets to foreign investments. The measures would include “significantly” lowering import tariffs for autos, enforcing intellectual property protection, and improving investment protections for foreign companies.

      Our views

      Xi’s speech is the kind that we expected. He is not a leader who thrives on populism and thus there wasn’t any emotionally charged over the top words or phrases. Xi is a leader who survives on internal party politics in a politically closed country. The reiteration of commitment to multilateral relationship is consistent with the party line to accuse US of protectionism.

      The pledges to open up the markets have been delivered by various Chinese leaders for two decades but actual delivery has been relatively small. And for now, these pledges remain words only. In addition, China still have the option of opening the markets to all but those who don’t commit to multilateral frameworks.

      So, does Xi’s speech do something to ease the trade tension with the US? Certainly not. Does it worsen the relationship? No neither. It’s like calling “check” playing poker. The ball is still on Trump’s court.

      Below is Xi’s speech with English translation voice over.

      YouTube

      By loading the video, you agree to YouTube’s privacy policy.
      Learn more

      Load video

       

      CAD surges on BoC Business Outlook Survey, CADJPY resuming rebound

        Canadian Dollar surges as BoC’s Business Outlook Survey painted a positive picture. In particular, business sentiments were supported by “healthy” sales prospects. Capacity and labor pressures are “evident” in most regions due to strong demand.

        Here are highlights of the survey:

        • Forward-looking sales indicators remain positive across most regions and sectors. Some firms expect a moderation in sales activity from high levels in the past year or a gradual slowing of the pace of the recovery in the energy sector.
        • While firms’ expectations for US economic growth have strengthened further, some cited rising protectionism and reduced competitiveness as factors limiting the impact on their sales.
        • Although less so than in recent surveys, intentions to increase investment continue to be widespread. Employment intentions are solidly positive, based on firms’ plans for hiring to support expected sales growth or to expand operations.
        • Indicators of capacity pressures and labour shortages edged down but are still close to recent high levels. Remaining economic slack appears to be mostly concentrated in the energy-producing regions.
        • Despite expectations for faster input price growth overall, on balance, firms continue to anticipate only modest acceleration in the growth of their output prices due to competitive pressures. Partly driven by rising labour costs, inflation expectations picked up but are still well within the Bank’s inflation-control range of 1 to 3 per cent.
        • While credit conditions were unchanged for most firms, the indicator points to a slight tightening.
        • The Business Outlook Survey indicator continues to be high, signalling positive business sentiment.

        Full release here

        CAD is now the second strongest for the day while JPY remains the weakest one.

        H action bias in CADJPY turned positive again.

        CADJPY’s retreat was contained above 83.36 support, maintaining near term bullishness. The rebound from 80.52 is likely ready to resume for 38.2% retracement of 91.56 to 80.52 at 84.73.

        ECB Draghi and Constancio struck cautious tones

          ECB President Mario Draghi sounded cautious as usual in today’s comments. Here are some highlights:

          • “While we remain confident that inflation will converge towards our aim over the medium term, there are still uncertainties about the degree of slack in the economy,”
          • “A patient, persistent and prudent monetary policy therefore remains necessary to ensure that inflation will return to our objective,”

          Regarding recent stock market volatility, Draghi sounded calm though as he noted:

          • “These risks materialized in global equity markets in early 2018, although to date without significant spillovers to euro area credit markets and hence broader financial conditions.”

          ECB Vice President Vitor Constancio also spoke today:

          • “Inflation, which is our objective, has not yet responded completely to what we wish to see.”
          • “We have confidence that inflation will continue to evolve…(but) we should be cautious in order to avoid that some early, strongly restrictive policy could derail this development,” he added.

          China considering Yuan devaluation as trade weapon against US?

            Bloomberg reported that Chinese officials are studying the impact of yuan depreciation on two fronts. Firstly, analysis was taken to look at using currency depreciation as a weapon in the trade war with the US. Secondly, it’s also studied how yuan depreciation could help offset any trade deal with US that curb exports.

            However, one important point to note is that the source for the information is obviously unnamed. And further than that, Bloomberg just said it’s from “people familiar with the matter”. So it looks unlikely that the information is from any Chinese officials.

            At the same time, it’s firstly seen by many that yuan devaluation could destabilize the China’s own markets, and that could do more harm to itself than to the US. And more important, China has been trying to portrait itself as rule follower that complies with the WTO book. It keeps blaming the US for unilateralism and protectionism and tries to to use that to draw international support. Devaluation of the Yuan will put China up against other countries too.

            President Xi Jinping probably won’t mind US President Donald Trump reiterating the label that China is a currency manipulator. But he most certainly doesn’t prefer other countries to jump on that bandwagon.

            So, while the news is currently in Bloomberg’s headline, its accuracy is suspectable.

            Eurozone Sentix expectations turned negative, significant economic slowdown must now be assumed

              Eurozone Sentix investor confidence dropped notably to 19.6 in April, down from 24.0 and missed expectation of 19.6. Current situation index dropped from 24.0 to 19.6, continuing the decline fro January’s high of 32.9. Expectation index turned negative to -1.5, down from March’s 4.3. That’s also a continuation of the fall from 18.8 back in January.

              Highlights from the release:

              • All regions of the world are on an economic downturn in April. Despite the still good assessment of the situation, there is no doubt that the global economy is cooling off.
              • Expectations for the Euro area are negative again for the first time since July 2016. The downward dynamic for Germany is even more pronounced.
              • The euphoria for the US economy is also fading noticeably. Expectations drop to a value of -7 percentage points. Trump’s statements and measures on punitive tariffs raise serious concerns. The component for Expectations of the sentix Global Aggregate falls to its lowest value since February 2016.

              Regarding Eurozone, the report noted that clear visible cooling. And, “after the declines in expectations had already indicated a turnaround in the previous months, a significant economic slowdown must now be assumed.” And, “the customs disputes, fueled by US President Donald Trump, are leaving their traces.”

              Regarding the US, Sentix noted that “observers rely on the common sense of the US government and assume that the demands are merely negotiation tactics.” But it warned that “Trump is consistently working through its ‘America first’ agenda”. And, The positive effects of the tax reform have quickly evaporated, and expectations for the US economy are plummeting.

              Full release here.

              Also released in European session, German trade surplus narrowed to EUR 19.2b in February. Swiss unemployment rate was unchanged at 2.9% in March.

              USD won’t stay noncommittal for long, as Dollar Index breakout imminent

                The forex markets is rather steady today so far. As seen in the D heatmap, most pairs are staying inside Friday’s range. AUD is trading as the strongest one while JPY is the weakest. This is a reflection of risk appetite in the Asian markets, with Nikkei and HSI trading up as the week starts. USD is mixed for now, up against EUR, JPY and CHF, but down against GBP, CAD, AUD and NZD.

                Movements in USD has been somewhat noncommittal recently, EUR/USD broke 1.2238 support last week but quickly recovered after hitting 1.2214. USD/CHF breached 0.9626 key fibonacci resistance but couldn’t found any follow through buying. Momentum in USD/JPY was also weak even though it extended recent rebound to 107.48. AUD/USD is staying in range above 0.7642 support. The clearer movements were seen in GBP/USD’s rebound after hitting 1.3982 support, but that mainly due to GBP’s strength. USD/CAD’s break of 1.2814 also suggests bearish reversal.

                Nonetheless, we might be seen some decisive moves in USD soon. The index is now approaching medium term trend line resistance, and a breakout is likely imminent. For now, there is no sign of a trend reversal yet. And the fall from 103.82 (2017 high) is more likely to extend than not. Break of 88.25 will pave the way to 61.8% retracement of 72.69 to 130.82 at 84.58. We maintain the view that fall from 103.82 is a corrective move. And strong support is expected from 84.58/75 to contain downside and bring sustainable rebound finally.

                DOW’s triangle pattern in shape

                  Asian markets are trading generally firmer today despite the selloff in the US on Friday. At the time of writing. Nikkei is trading up 0.65%. China’s SSE is back from holiday and is up 0.35%. Hong Kong HSI is up more than 1.8%.

                  However, we’d like to point out that risks for deeper global market selloff remains. As we pointed out in the weekly report too, DOW’s triangle pattern is in shape after Friday’s selloff.

                  DOW’s rejection from 55 day EMA, below the near term trend line, and Friday’s selloff set up the pattern from 23360.29 to be a triangle consolidation pattern. Immediate focus will be back on 23360.29 this week. Overall, price actions from 26616.71 record high are seen as correcting the up trend from 2016 low at 15450.56. We’d expect deeper decline before the correction completes. And break of 23360.29 will target 38.2% retracement of 15450.56 to 26616.71 at 22351.24.

                  China CASS Zhang: There should be a firewall between trade and finance

                    Talking about the Boao Forum, there is one interesting point to note. On Sunday, head of the Institute of World Economics and Politics at the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences Zhang Yuyan said there is no intention of allowing trade dispute with the US to spill over to finance. Zhang emphasized that there should be a “firewall between trade problems and financial ones”. And, the chance of China selling its massive US Treasury holdings due to a trade war is “very small”.

                    Zhang added that “maybe one or two days before the actual implementation (of the tariffs), the US side will gain its reason and sense.” And, “there are many cases of compromises being reached at the last minute.”

                    China Xi’s speech at Boao Forum may disappoint

                      Chinese President Xi Jinping’s speech at the Boao Forum for Asia on Tuesday will be a key focus this week. Xi has so far been quiet regarding the trade tensions with US President Donald Trump. There are expectations for Xi to make use of the occasion to push back and defend. Or, Xi could say something consistent with China’s theme of blaming US for unilaterialism and protectionism,

                      However, Xi’s leadership and communication style is clearly very different from Trump’s. And it’s, to us, unlikely for Xi to suddenly change his style to adopt a confrontational way like Trump. That is, the way that Trump tripled down on the tariff proposals to USD 150b immediately after Chinese response. Nor would Xi adopt a way like Trump, who could say “President Xi and I will always be friends” right after raising the threat to China. We’ve never heard Xi saying that Trump is his friend (haven you?). It’s more likely for Xi to just reiterate the push for globalization, compliance with then WTO and its own commitment in opening up the markets. Xi, as self-envisaged emperor, will just let his officials do the barking.

                      Anticipated symbolic NAFTA agreement might not be reached

                        Reuters reported that Trump’s push for some form of NAFTA “agreement” before the Summit of the Americas in Lima could fail. It’s widely rumored that Trump would at least want to have something “symbolic” to sign this week. But there are still many fundamental differences between the US with its NAFTA partners Canada and Mexico.

                        A source was quoted saying that even a symbolic agreement needs to contain “everything defined in black and white” and key issues could not be left open for negotiation afterwards. The source noted that a deal could be possible by the end of April or early May if discussions keep advancing.

                        It should be noted that CAD has been strongest one this month as seen in the monthly top movers table, as well as the M heatmap. It’s mainly due to optimism that a certain form of NAFTA agreement could be delivered at the Summit of the Americas on April 13-14, or before. There is firstly, risk of sell-on-news, if the agreement is delivered. There is now secondly, risk of selloff on disappointment that it’s not delivered. So, CAD traders, beware.

                        Fed Kashkari: Trade war uncertainty scaring people a little bit

                          Minneapolis Fed President Neel Kashkari urged fed policy makers “should all be paying attention” to the escalation in trade tension between Trump and China. For now, “it’s too soon for any of us to judge” and “none of us knows how to weigh the probability of these different outcomes.” And, “how that washes out in overall inflation I think is hard to judge.”

                          He said the impact to the economy is unknown for the moment as “this could be a lot of chest pounding”. Or, “it could lead to a trade war.” The end results, even something in the middle as usual during negotiations, could prompt business and investors to “pull back” and that could impact economic growth. Also, “the impact on Main Street is going to be seen over the long term.”

                          Kashkari also noted that “uncertainty I think is scaring people a little bit.”

                          Fed dove Evans supports more rate hikes

                            Chicago Fed Charles Evans, a clearly known dove, expressed his optimism that inflation will hit 2% target and support for gradual rate hike on Saturday. He pointed to fiscal policy that “has been much more supportive of further growth”. Hence, “the need for accommodative monetary policy is less than it was before.”

                            And, now, given the “very strong” national economy and labor market, he would be surprised is inflation couldn’t meet target. Evans added, “continuing our slow, gradual increases will be appropriate to get us to the point where monetary policy isn’t really providing more lift to the economy.”

                            Fed Powell: Connection between unemployment and inflation “still persists”

                              Fed chair Jerome Powell sounded upbeat in his speech on ” The Outlook for the U.S. Economy” last Friday. He acknowledged that “the labor market has been strong, and my colleagues and I on the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) expect it to remain strong.” And, inflation is expected to ” move up in coming months and to stabilize around 2 percent over the medium term.” Powell also pointed to others signs of strengthen including “steady income gains, rising household wealth, and elevated consumer confidence”. Powell also noted that the connection between unemployment rate and inflation has “clearly weakened” over the past couple of decades. But he emphasized that the connection “still persists”. And “it continues to be meaningful for monetary policy.”

                              Regarding monetary policy, Powell said that “as long as the economy continues broadly on its current path, further gradual increases in the federal funds rate will best promote these goals” of price stability and full employment. He repeated what others have said that ” raising rates too slowly would make it necessary for monetary policy to tighten abruptly down the road, which could jeopardize the economic expansion.” On the other hand, “raising rates too quickly would increase the risk that inflation would remain persistently below our 2 percent objective.” And Fed’s gradual path is aiming at balancing these two risks.

                              Regarding recent tensions between Trump and China on trade, Powell noted that “the discussion about trade is at a relatively early stage”. And, “people really don’t see yet any impact for the near-term outlook.” However, he did noted that business leaders have already expressed their concerns to Fed officials that “changes in trade policy have become a risk to the medium-term outlook.”

                              Briefer than brief press briefing of China MOFCOM

                                China Ministry of Commerce Spokesman Gao Feng delivered a rather unimpressive briefing, in response to US President Donald Trump’s proposal of tariffs on additional USD 100b of products. Gao just said that US action is extremely wrong, and with misjudgment in the situation. He pledged that China is ready and won’t hesitate to retaliate. And there will be immediately action is the US releases the USD 100b tariff list. Gao claimed that China has very detailed retaliatory measures.

                                Basically, Gao just said that we’re ready to hit the ball back hard. But it’s now still in your court.

                                Big miss for headline NFP, but wage growth solid. USD/CAD dives

                                  US non farm payrolls come in much weaker than expected, showing 103k growth in March only, versus expectation of 189k. Prior month’s figure was revised up from 313k to 326k. Unemployment rate was unchanged at 4.1% versus expectation of 4.0%. Nonetheless, average hourly earnings rose 0.3% mom, meeting expectation.

                                  Canada employment grew 32.3k in March, way above expectation of 20k. Unemployment rate was unchanged at 5.8%, meeting consensus.

                                  Dollar is trading lower against most major currencies on the head line NFP number. It remains to be seen if the solid wage growth number could give it enough support.

                                  USD/CAD is at the center of attention regarding the batch data in early US session. Apparently, market are responding with a selloff in the pair after the releases.

                                  Markets steady as traders await China press briefing on US tariffs

                                    While news that Trump is pushing for additional tariffs on another USD 100b of Chinese imports might raise some eyebrows, markets reactions are so far muted. At the time of writing, DAX is trading down -0.47%, CAC down -0.45% and FTSE down -0.19% only. The forex markets are bounded in yesterday’s range in general, except that some weakness is seen in NZD.

                                    Traders are most likely waiting for a formal response from China. The MOFCOM is going to hold a press briefing at 8pm Beijing time, 1200GMT today, while the country is on holiday.

                                    Separately, South Korea has notified WTO of the plan to suspend tariff concessions on USD 480m of US imports, in response to US measures against the country. The Trade Ministry said it’s in equal value to South Korean washing machines and solar panels affected by the US tariffs.

                                    ECB Cœuré: “Winding back globalisation is the wrong solution”

                                      ECB Executive Board member Benoît Cœuré warned of “consequence of protectionism” in a speech at a workshop today.

                                      A few from the speech to note:

                                      • “Greater global economic integration has boosted living standards worldwide and lifted millions out of poverty.”
                                      • “Winding back globalisation is the wrong solution.” And, “a retreat from openness will only fuel more inequality as import prices rise, goods become dearer and real incomes fall.”
                                      • “The distributional and social effects of greater economic integration should rather be addressed by targeted policies that achieve fairer outcomes.”
                                      • “By allowing Member States to recover some of the state functions that have been eroded by globalisation, the European Union is a vehicle that brings the benefits of economic openness to the greatest number of its citizens while protecting them against untrammelled global forces. It represents the most progressive model we have for taking back control of globalisation by addressing people’s concerns over open markets and fair competition – doubts that individual countries on their own cannot dispel.”

                                      Here is the full speech.

                                      China pledges to figh US unilateralism and protectionism “to the end, and at any cost”

                                        The Ministry of Commerce issued a quick response to Trump’s intention to add tariffs to additional USD 100b of Chinese imports, while they’re on holiday.

                                        In a statement, China pledged to fight US unilateralism and protectionism “to the end, and at any cost”. And China will “firmly attack, using new comprehensive countermeasures, to firmly defend the interest of the nation and its people.”

                                        The MOFCOM blamed that the the US “single-handedly started the trade conflicts”. And it added that it’s “provocation of unilateralism of the US to global free trade”.

                                        This is sort of the expected response from China.

                                        Here is the statement from MOFCOM (in Simplified Chinese).

                                        NFP Expectation: 189k growth, unemployment to drop to 4.0%, wage growth at 0.3%

                                          While the trade war drama continues, with intention of escalation from Trump, there are other issues that’s worth a look. Non-farm payroll report is still a major focus of the day.

                                          Markets are expecting NFP to show 189k growth in March, down from February’s 313k. Unemployment rate is expected to drop further to 4.0%. Wage growth remains the key for Fed’s tightening path. Average hourly earnings are expected to grow 0.3% mom in March.

                                          Here is a summary of preceding job data:

                                          • ADP private sector jobs grew a solid 241k
                                          • ISM manufacturing employment dropped to 57.3, down fro 59.7
                                          • ISM non-manufacturing employment rose to 56.6, up from 55.0
                                          • Conference board consumer confidence dropped to 127.7, down from 130.0

                                          The data were solid even though they don’t point to that stellar 313k job growth in February. But 189k should be easy to achieve.

                                          Here are some other NFP previews that’s worth a look: